Comparing Cooling Bodies: Specific Heat and Steady Temperature
With the same surface and the same temperature range, a body that stores more heat cools more slowly: the cooling time is proportional to its heat capacity. That is the method of cooling for specific heats, and the same law gives the power a heater needs to hold a steady temperature.
A calorimeter cools from 60 °C to 40 °C in 18 minutes; with a metal block inside, in 20 minutes. The extra time gives the metal's specific heat.
Same surface, same range.Loss ∝ temperature difference.
Steady temperature
Heater power = heat loss
At a steady temperature the heater's power equals the rate of heat loss, which is proportional to T−Ts.
Summary
Key formulas
tT1−T2=msK[2T1+T2−Ts] Comparing bodies: heat capacity, specific heat and steady temperature
dtdQ=α(T−Ts) Comparing bodies: heat capacity, specific heat and steady temperature
Worked examples
One for every idea
Comparing bodies: heat capacity, specific heat and steady temperature
1. A calorimeter of water equivalent 100 g cools from 60 °C to 40 °C in 18 minutes. With a 60 g metal block at 60 °C inside, the system cools over the same range in 20 minutes. Find the specific heat of the metal.
Same surface and range: time ∝ heat capacity, 1820=100100+60s.
100+60s=111.1.
s≈0.185 cal g⁻¹ °C⁻¹.
Comparing bodies: heat capacity, specific heat and steady temperature
2. A 1 kg metal ball is heated by a 20 W heater in a room at 20 °C until its temperature is steady at 50 °C. Find its rate of heat loss at 50 °C and at 30 °C.
Steady at 50 °C: loss = heater power = 20 W.
20=K(50−20)⇒K=32 W/°C.
At 50 °C: 20 W. At 30 °C: 32×10≈6.67 W.
JEE-style question
Your turn
Two solid spheres of the same material, of radii r and 2r, are at the same temperature in the same surroundings. The ratio of their initial rates of cooling (smaller : larger) is:
(a)1 : 4
(b)2 : 1
(c)1 : 2
(d)1 : 1
Show the answer and the traps
Rate of cooling ∝ A/m ∝ r²/r³ = 1/r. The small one cools twice as fast: 2 : 1, option b.
1 : 4 is the ratio of the rates of heat loss, which go as area.
1 : 2 turns the answer upside down.
And 1 : 1 forgets that the mass grows faster than the area.
Watch out
Common mistakes
Comparing cooling times of bodies with different surfacesThe method needs the same surface, surroundings and temperature range.
Practice
Try these
1. Two liquids of equal mass in identical containers cool over the same range in 6 and 9 minutes (neglect the containers). Find the ratio of their specific heats.
Time ∝ ms: s1:s2=6:9=2:3.
2. A heater keeps a body at 60 °C in a room at 20 °C using 40 W. What power keeps it at 40 °C?
Loss ∝ T−Ts: 40×4020=20 W.
3. (Book, PE 4.3 v) 100 g of water at 40 °C in a calorimeter of negligible heat capacity cools to 35 °C in 5 min. The same volume of a liquid (2100 J/kg °C) cools over the same range in 2 min. Find the liquid's density (water 4200 J/kg °C).
Time ∝ ms: 52=0.1×4200m×2100⇒m=0.08 kg in 100 cm³, so 800 kg/m³.