layrd.liveLayer by Layer
ChemistryReaction MechanismsJEE · NEET
  1. 1. Inductive Effect
  2. 2. Carboxylic Acid Strength
  3. 3. Alcohols, Hydrocarbons, Amines
  4. 4. Electromeric & Mesomeric
  5. 5. Hyperconjugation
  6. 6. Fission & Free Radicals
  7. 7. Carbocations
  8. 8. Carbanions
  9. 9. Carbenes
  10. 10. Nitrenes & Benzyne
  11. 11. Electrophiles & Nucleophiles
  12. 12. Reaction Types
  13. 13. Free Radical Substitution
  14. 14. SN2 Reaction
  15. 15. SN1 Reaction
  16. 16. SN1 vs SN2
  17. 17. Electrophilic Substitution
  18. 18. Markovnikov's Rule
  19. 19. Br₂ Addition & Dienes
  20. 20. Peroxide Effect
  21. 21. Nucleophilic Addition
  22. 22. E1, E1cB & Saytzeff
  23. 23. E2 Elimination
Reaction Mechanisms · Part 1 of 23

Inductive Effect: −I and +I Groups

A polar σ bond doesn't keep its polarity to itself: the δ+ carbon pulls on its neighbour, which pulls on the next, with the charge shrinking at every step. This permanent, short-range relay is the inductive effect, and comparing groups with hydrogen gives the −I and +I series used throughout the chapter.

Inductive Effect: −I and +I GroupsVideo coming soon
The language

Substrate + reagent → intermediate → products

The reagent attacks the substrate. Most reactions pass through short-lived intermediates, and the step-by-step path is the mechanism. Positive reagents attack electron-rich sites, negative reagents electron-poor ones.

Flow from substrate and reagent through an intermediate to products, with four idea chips.
The four ideas the chapter builds on: electron displacements, bond fission, reagents, intermediates.
A chain C4–C3–C2–C1–Cl with shrinking delta-plus labels and arrowheads in the middle of each bond.
C₁ δ+ > C₂ δδ+ > C₃ δδδ+.
Inductive effect

δ+ relayed along the chain

Chlorine pulls the C–Cl σ pair: C₁ becomes δ+, C₂ a smaller δδ+, C₃ smaller still. Beyond the second carbon the effect is negligible. The arrowhead in the middle of each bond shows the direction of the pull.

The series

−I and +I groups

The C–H bond is the standard. Groups that pull harder than H are −I (electron-withdrawing); groups that push harder are +I (electron-releasing). Phenyl and vinyl are weakly −I because an sp² carbon is more electronegative.

The −I order from NR3+ down to vinyl, hydrogen at zero, and the +I order of alkyl groups.
+I grows with the number of methyl groups on the attached carbon.
Bar chart of the dipole moments of CH3I, CH3Br and CH3Cl.
The inductive effect changes physical properties and reaction rates.
Consequence

Dipole moments of methyl halides

CH₃I 1.64 D < CH₃Br 1.79 D < CH₃Cl 1.83 D (book values). C–Cl is the shortest of the three bonds, yet the most polar: the charge separation decides.

Summary

Key formulas

Consequences: alkyl halide reactivity and dipole moment
Worked examples

One for every idea

Substrate, reagent, intermediate and mechanism

1. In , name the substrate and the reagent, and the site of attack.

  1. is the species attacked: the substrate.
  2. does the attacking: the reagent.
  3. A negative reagent attacks an electron-poor site: the carbon bonded to Cl.

Substrate , reagent , attacking the δ+ carbon.

Origin and transmission of the inductive effect

2. In 1-bromopropane, which carbon carries the largest partial positive charge, and roughly how much does C₃ feel the bromine?

  1. C₁ is bonded to Br, which pulls the σ pair: C₁ gets δ+.
  2. C₂ receives a smaller δδ+ by relay through the C₁–C₂ bond.
  3. The effect is negligible beyond the second carbon.

C₁ carries the largest δ+; C₃ feels almost nothing.

−I and +I groups and their order

3. Arrange –CN, –F, –OH and –C₆H₅ in decreasing order of −I effect.

  1. Read the −I series: NR₃⁺ > NO₂ > SO₂R > CN > COOH > F > Cl > Br > I > OR > COR > OH > C₆H₅ > CH=CH₂ > H.

–CN > –F > –OH > –C₆H₅.

−I and +I groups and their order

4. Which releases electrons more strongly by the inductive effect: an isopropyl group or an ethyl group? Why?

  1. +I grows with the number of methyl groups on the attached carbon.
  2. (CH₃)₂CH– has two; CH₃CH₂– has one.

Isopropyl is the stronger +I group.

Consequences: alkyl halide reactivity and dipole moment

5. Explain why chloromethane reacts with a negatively charged reagent while methane does not.

  1. In CH₃Cl the C–Cl bond is polarised: C δ+, Cl δ−.
  2. The δ+ carbon is a low-electron-density site that attracts the negative reagent.
  3. Methane's C–H bonds are almost non-polar, so it has no such site.

Only CH₃Cl has an electron-poor (δ+) carbon for the reagent to attack.

JEE-style question

Your turn

Which group has the strongest −I effect?

(a)–F
(b)–NO₂
(c)–CN
(d)–COOH
Show the answer and the traps

–NO₂, option b. It is near the very top of the −I series, just below –NR₃⁺.

–F is the strongest halogen, but it comes after NO₂, CN and COOH.

–CN is strong, but it sits below –NO₂.

And –COOH sits below –CN.

Watch out

Common mistakes

Thinking the inductive effect moves electrons completely or carries along the whole chainIt is a partial displacement and dies out after about two carbons.
Calling phenyl and vinyl +I groupsIn this series they are weakly −I: an sp² carbon is more electronegative.
Forgetting deuteriumD is slightly +I compared with H.
Assuming dipole moment follows bond lengthCH₃Cl has the largest dipole of the methyl halides although C–Cl is the shortest bond.
Practice

Try these

1. Which group has zero inductive effect by definition? (a) –CH₃ (b) –H (c) –Cl (d) –C₆H₅

(b) –H: the C–H bond is the standard against which −I and +I are measured.

2. Arrange in decreasing −I effect: –Cl, –NO₂, –COOH, –I.

–NO₂ > –COOH > –Cl > –I.

3. Arrange in decreasing +I effect: –CH₃, –C(CH₃)₃, –CH(CH₃)₂, –H.

–C(CH₃)₃ > –CH(CH₃)₂ > –CH₃ > –H (more methyls on the attached carbon, stronger +I).

4. Why is the effect of a chlorine atom on a carbon chain negligible beyond the second carbon?

Each carbon passes on only part of the pull it feels, so the charges shrink quickly: δ+ > δδ+ > δδδ+.

5. CH₃Cl has a larger dipole moment than CH₃I although the C–I bond is longer. Explain.

Cl is much more electronegative than I, so the charge separation in C–Cl is far greater; that outweighs the shorter bond (1.83 D vs 1.64 D).

All 23 partsChapter hub