A carbocation is a carbon with a positive charge and only six electrons: sp², trigonal planar, with an empty p orbital waiting for a nucleophile. Anything that spreads the charge stabilises it: alkyl groups (+I and hyperconjugation), an adjacent lone pair that completes every octet, and resonance in allyl and benzyl cations.
Heterolysis of a halide ((CHX3)X3C−Cl(CHX3)X3CX++ClX−), protonation of an alcohol or alkene (ROHHX+ROHX2X+RX++HX2O), or loss of NX2 from a diazonium ion (CX6HX5NX2X+CX6HX5X++NX2).
Three routes to C⁺.Trigonal planar carbocation.
Structure
sp², planar, empty p
The cationic carbon has six electrons in three bonds 120° apart; the empty p orbital stands at right angles to the plane and is where nucleophiles attack.
Protonate, then lose water.More alkyl groups, more stable.
Stability
3° > 2° > 1° > CH₃⁺
Alkyl groups spread the positive charge by +I and hyperconjugation (9, 6, 3, 0 α-H). Among primary cations a longer chain helps slightly.
Lone pair
CHX3O−CHX2X+CHX3OX+=CHX2
An adjacent oxygen (or nitrogen) shares its lone pair so every atom has an octet; such cations are more stable than even 3° alkyl cations. −I groups (NO₂, CN, Br) destabilise.
Full octets beat hyperconjugation.Allyl: 2 forms.
Resonance
The allyl cation
Two resonance forms put the positive charge on either end carbon.
Resonance
The benzyl cation
Four forms spread the charge to the two ortho carbons and the para carbon. Allyl and benzyl cations are almost equally stable.
Benzyl: 4 forms.Reactivity runs the other way.
Overview
Carbocation stability
(CX6HX5)X3CX+, tropylium > CHX3O−CHX2X+ > benzyl ≈ allyl ≈ 3° > 2° > 1° > CHX3X+. Cyclopropylmethyl cations beat benzyl. The book's lists disagree on benzyl, allyl and 3°; in solution they are about equal, so read the options.
Worked example
p-Methoxy vs p-nitro
The para-OCH₃ lone pair reaches the CHX2X+ (a form with + on O and full octets); para-NO₂ withdraws and adds positive charge to the ring.
p-OCH₃ > p-CH₃ > H > p-NO₂.
Worked examples
One for every idea
Formation, structure and reactions
1. Show how propan-2-ol gives a carbocation in acid, and state the hybridisation and shape of the cation.
(CHX3)X2CHOH+HX+(CHX3)X2CH−OHX2X+.
Water leaves: (CHX3)X2CHX++HX2O.
The cationic carbon is sp², trigonal planar, with a vacant p orbital.
Stability order of carbocations
2. Arrange in decreasing stability: CHX3CHX2X+, (CHX3)X2CHX+, CHX3OCHX2X+, CHX3X+.
CHX3OCHX2X+: the O lone pair gives CHX3OX+=CHX2 with full octets.