layrd.liveLayer by Layer
ChemistryReaction MechanismsJEE · NEET
  1. 1. Inductive Effect
  2. 2. Carboxylic Acid Strength
  3. 3. Alcohols, Hydrocarbons, Amines
  4. 4. Electromeric & Mesomeric
  5. 5. Hyperconjugation
  6. 6. Fission & Free Radicals
  7. 7. Carbocations
  8. 8. Carbanions
  9. 9. Carbenes
  10. 10. Nitrenes & Benzyne
  11. 11. Electrophiles & Nucleophiles
  12. 12. Reaction Types
  13. 13. Free Radical Substitution
  14. 14. SN2 Reaction
  15. 15. SN1 Reaction
  16. 16. SN1 vs SN2
  17. 17. Electrophilic Substitution
  18. 18. Markovnikov's Rule
  19. 19. Br₂ Addition & Dienes
  20. 20. Peroxide Effect
  21. 21. Nucleophilic Addition
  22. 22. E1, E1cB & Saytzeff
  23. 23. E2 Elimination
Reaction Mechanisms · Part 7 of 23

Carbocations: Structure and Stability

A carbocation is a carbon with a positive charge and only six electrons: sp², trigonal planar, with an empty p orbital waiting for a nucleophile. Anything that spreads the charge stabilises it: alkyl groups (+I and hyperconjugation), an adjacent lone pair that completes every octet, and resonance in allyl and benzyl cations.

Builds on: Part 6 · Bond Fission and Free Radicals.

Carbocations: Structure and StabilityVideo coming soon
Formation

Making a carbocation

Heterolysis of a halide (), protonation of an alcohol or alkene (), or loss of from a diazonium ion ().

Three reactions that form carbocations.
Three routes to C⁺.
3D model of a planar methyl cation with its empty p orbital.
Trigonal planar carbocation.
Structure

sp², planar, empty p

The cationic carbon has six electrons in three bonds 120° apart; the empty p orbital stands at right angles to the plane and is where nucleophiles attack.

Worked example

Propan-2-ol in acid

.

Propan-2-ol, its oxonium ion and the isopropyl cation.
Protonate, then lose water.
Ladder of tertiary, secondary, primary and methyl cations.
More alkyl groups, more stable.
Stability

3° > 2° > 1° > CH₃⁺

Alkyl groups spread the positive charge by +I and hyperconjugation (9, 6, 3, 0 α-H). Among primary cations a longer chain helps slightly.

Lone pair

An adjacent oxygen (or nitrogen) shares its lone pair so every atom has an octet; such cations are more stable than even 3° alkyl cations. −I groups (NO₂, CN, Br) destabilise.

Methoxymethyl cation and its oxonium resonance form.
Full octets beat hyperconjugation.
The allyl cation and its resonance form.
Allyl: 2 forms.
Resonance

The allyl cation

Two resonance forms put the positive charge on either end carbon.

Resonance

The benzyl cation

Four forms spread the charge to the two ortho carbons and the para carbon. Allyl and benzyl cations are almost equally stable.

Benzyl cation and its ring forms with + at ortho and para.
Benzyl: 4 forms.
Ladder of carbocations from triphenylmethyl down to methyl.
Reactivity runs the other way.
Overview

Carbocation stability

, tropylium > > benzyl ≈ allyl ≈ 3° > 2° > 1° > . Cyclopropylmethyl cations beat benzyl. The book's lists disagree on benzyl, allyl and 3°; in solution they are about equal, so read the options.

Worked example

p-Methoxy vs p-nitro

The para-OCH₃ lone pair reaches the (a form with + on O and full octets); para-NO₂ withdraws and adds positive charge to the ring.

p-Methoxybenzyl cation with its oxonium form, and the p-nitrobenzyl cation.
p-OCH₃ > p-CH₃ > H > p-NO₂.
Worked examples

One for every idea

Formation, structure and reactions

1. Show how propan-2-ol gives a carbocation in acid, and state the hybridisation and shape of the cation.

  1. .
  2. Water leaves: .

The cationic carbon is sp², trigonal planar, with a vacant p orbital.

Stability order of carbocations

2. Arrange in decreasing stability: , , , .

  1. : the O lone pair gives with full octets.
  2. Then α-H: 6, 3, 0.

.

Stability order of carbocations

3. Which is more stable, the p-methoxybenzyl cation or the p-nitrobenzyl cation? Why?

  1. donates its lone pair (+M) into the ring and onto the .
  2. withdraws (−M, −I) and puts more positive charge on the ring.

p-Methoxybenzyl.

JEE-style question

Your turn

Which carbocation is the most reactive?

(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
Show the answer and the traps

CH₃⁺, option d: the least stable cation is the most reactive.

(CH₃)₃C⁺ is the most stable, so the least reactive.

(CH₃)₂CH⁺ is held back by 6 α-H.

And CH₃CH₂⁺ by 3.

Watch out

Common mistakes

Confusing reactivity with stabilityThe least stable cation () is the most reactive.
Assuming the n-propyl cation is resonance-stabilised like allylIt has no π bond next to C⁺.
Calling the carbocation carbon sp³ or tetrahedralIt is sp² and trigonal planar, with an empty p orbital.
Practice

Try these

1. Which carbocation is the most stable? (a) (b) (c) (d)

(d): the charge spreads over three rings.

2. Arrange in decreasing stability: , , , .

.

3. Why is more stable than ?

N's lone pair forms , in which every atom has an octet.

4. What is the hybridisation of the cationic carbon in the benzyl cation, and how many resonance forms does it have?

sp²; four forms (charge on CH₂, two ortho carbons and the para carbon).

5. Give the carbocation formed when benzenediazonium chloride loses .

The phenyl cation, .

All 23 partsChapter hub