layrd.liveLayer by Layer
ChemistryReaction MechanismsJEE · NEET
  1. 1. Inductive Effect
  2. 2. Carboxylic Acid Strength
  3. 3. Alcohols, Hydrocarbons, Amines
  4. 4. Electromeric & Mesomeric
  5. 5. Hyperconjugation
  6. 6. Fission & Free Radicals
  7. 7. Carbocations
  8. 8. Carbanions
  9. 9. Carbenes
  10. 10. Nitrenes & Benzyne
  11. 11. Electrophiles & Nucleophiles
  12. 12. Reaction Types
  13. 13. Free Radical Substitution
  14. 14. SN2 Reaction
  15. 15. SN1 Reaction
  16. 16. SN1 vs SN2
  17. 17. Electrophilic Substitution
  18. 18. Markovnikov's Rule
  19. 19. Br₂ Addition & Dienes
  20. 20. Peroxide Effect
  21. 21. Nucleophilic Addition
  22. 22. E1, E1cB & Saytzeff
  23. 23. E2 Elimination
Reaction Mechanisms · Part 8 of 23

Carbanions: Structure and Stability

A carbanion is a carbon that keeps the bonding pair: eight electrons, a negative charge, and a lone pair that makes it a nucleophile. Simple carbanions are pyramidal like ammonia. Everything that stabilised a carbocation now works in reverse: +I alkyl groups destabilise, while −I groups, s-character and resonance spread the charge.

Builds on: Part 7 · Carbocations: Structure and Stability.

Carbanions: Structure and StabilityVideo coming soon
Structure

Pyramidal, like ammonia

A simple carbanion is sp³ with its lone pair in one hybrid orbital, the same shape as . All electrons are paired, so it is diamagnetic.

3D models of the pyramidal methyl anion and ammonia with their lone-pair lobes.
and .
Ethyl acetoacetate, its carbanion and the enolate resonance form.
Resonance flattens a stabilised carbanion.
Worked example

Ethyl acetoacetate carbanion

Ethoxide removes an H from the between the two C=O groups. The carbanion carbon has 8 valence electrons; because its charge is shared with both carbonyl oxygens, it is planar (sp²) in practice, not sp³.

Stability

> 1° > 2° > 3°

+I alkyl groups push more charge onto the carbanion and destabilise it: the reverse of the carbocation order.

Ladder of methyl, primary, secondary and tertiary carbanions.
Alkyl groups destabilise carbanions.
Ladder of acetylide, vinyl and alkyl carbanions with their s-character.
The pair is held closer to the nucleus.
Hybridisation

More s-character, more stable

(50 % s) > (33 %) > (25 %).

Resonance

The benzyl anion

The charge spreads to the ortho and para carbons. > > ; substituted benzyl anions: p-NO₂ > H > p-CH₃ > p-OCH₃. The book lists benzyl and allyl above ; by (ethyne 25, toluene ≈ 41) the acetylide is actually the more stable anion.

Benzyl anion and its canonical forms with − at ortho and para.
Resonance stabilises allyl and benzyl anions.
Table comparing free radicals, carbocations and carbanions.
Only the carbanion is pyramidal.
Compare

Radical, cation, anion

Charge: neutral, +, −. Electrons: 7, 6, 8. Magnetism: para, dia, dia. Made by homolysis, heterolysis, heterolysis. Shape: sp² planar, sp² planar, sp³ pyramidal.

Worked example

, ,

The radical and the cation are planar; the anion is pyramidal.

3D models of the methyl radical, cation and anion.
Three methyl species in 3D.
Worked examples

One for every idea

Formation, structure and reactions

1. Ethyl acetoacetate loses a proton to ethoxide. Write the carbanion formed and give its hybridisation and electron count.

  1. .
  2. The carbanionic carbon has 8 valence electrons.
  3. Its charge is delocalised onto both C=O oxygens (enolate forms), which makes it planar.

8 electrons; a simple carbanion would be sp³, but this delocalised one is planar (sp²). (Corrected from the brief, which says sp³.)

Stability of carbanions

2. Arrange in decreasing stability: , , , .

  1. Benzyl: resonance with the ring.
  2. Vinyl: lone pair in an sp² orbital (33 % s).
  3. : no +I group; : three +I methyls.

. (Replaces the brief's set, where the book's benzyl > HC≡C⁻ conflicts with pKa data.)

Free radicals vs carbocations vs carbanions

3. Which of , and is (a) pyramidal, (b) paramagnetic, (c) isoelectronic with ?

  1. has a lone pair: sp³, pyramidal.
  2. has an unpaired electron.
  3. has 6 valence electrons and is planar, like .

(a) , (b) , (c) .

JEE-style question

Your turn

Which carbanion is the most stable?

(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
Show the answer and the traps

HC≡C⁻, option d: its pair sits in an sp orbital, 50% s-character.

CH₃CH₂⁻ has a +I methyl and only 25% s.

(CH₃)₃C⁻ is the least stable of all: three +I methyls.

And CH₂=CH⁻ is sp², 33% s: better, but not as good as sp.

Watch out

Common mistakes

Copying the carbocation order for carbanionsAlkyl groups destabilise carbanions, so 3° is the least stable.
Calling every carbanion sp³When the charge is delocalised into C=O or a ring, the carbon becomes planar.
Practice

Try these

1. The shape of is: (a) planar (b) linear (c) pyramidal (d) tetrahedral with no lone pair

(c) pyramidal.

2. Arrange in decreasing stability: , , , .

.

3. Why is more stable than ?

Its charge is delocalised over three rings instead of one.

4. Which is more stable: p-nitrobenzyl anion or p-methoxybenzyl anion?

p-Nitrobenzyl: NO₂ withdraws (−M, −I) and spreads the negative charge; OCH₃ donates and concentrates it.

5. How many valence electrons does the carbanionic carbon have, and is it a nucleophile or an electrophile?

8; a nucleophile (electron-rich).

All 23 partsChapter hub