In C=O the oxygen pulls the π electrons towards itself, so the carbonyl carbon is electron-poor and nucleophiles attack it. In the slow step the nucleophile bonds to carbon and the negative charge moves onto oxygen. A proton then completes the addition. Alkyl groups lower reactivity in two ways: their +I effect reduces δ+ on the carbon, and their bulk blocks the attack. So aldehydes react faster than ketones.
Step 1: HCNHX++CNX−. Step 2 (slow): CNX− attacks the carbonyl carbon, giving an alkoxide ion. The negative charge sits on oxygen, which holds it far better than carbon would hold a positive charge. Step 3 (fast): HX+ adds to O, giving acetone cyanohydrin.
The attacking species is CNX−, not HCN. A base (or KCN) raises [CNX−] and speeds the reaction; acid pushes HCNHX++CNX− to the left and slows it. Pure HCN hardly reacts.
Reactivity
Order towards nucleophiles
CClX3CHO > HCHO > CHX3CHO > CHX3CHX2CHO > CHX3COCHX3 > CHX3COCX6HX5 > CX6HX5COCX6HX5. Each +I alkyl group lowers δ+ and adds bulk; phenyl donates by resonance. CClX3 is −I, so chloral is the most reactive.
Aldehydes beat ketones.Withdrawing groups help.
Reactivity
Substituted benzaldehydes
p-NOX2 > p-X > p-CHX3 > p-OCHX3 benzaldehyde: electron-withdrawing groups raise δ+ on the carbonyl carbon, donating groups lower it.
More additions
Bisulphite, Grignard, acetylene
NaHSOX3 adds through S, giving a bisulphite compound. Grignard: >C=O+RMgX>C(R)OMgX, then water gives the alcohol. Acetylene + HCN (Ba(CN)X2) → acrylonitrile and acetylene + CHX3OH (KOH) → methyl vinyl ether, with CNX− and CHX3OX− as the attacking species.
Same pattern every time.R attacks, water finishes.
Worked example
Ethanal + CH₃MgBr
The carbanion-like CHX3 attacks the carbonyl carbon, giving (CHX3)X2CH−OMgBr; water then gives propan-2-ol.
Worked examples
One for every idea
Mechanism: addition of HCN
1. Why does the addition of HCN to propanal speed up when a little KCN is added, and slow down in strong acid?
The nucleophile is CNX−; it attacks the carbonyl carbon in the slow step.
KCN supplies CNX− directly.
Strong acid pushes HCNHX++CNX− to the left, removing CNX−.
The rate depends on [CN⁻]: KCN raises it, acid lowers it.
Reactivity order of carbonyl compounds
2. Arrange in decreasing reactivity towards HCN: acetone, benzaldehyde, formaldehyde, acetaldehyde.
Formaldehyde: two H, no +I, no bulk. Acetaldehyde: one methyl.
Benzaldehyde: phenyl lowers δ+ by resonance, but it is still an aldehyde.