layrd.liveLayer by Layer
ChemistryReaction MechanismsJEE · NEET
  1. 1. Inductive Effect
  2. 2. Carboxylic Acid Strength
  3. 3. Alcohols, Hydrocarbons, Amines
  4. 4. Electromeric & Mesomeric
  5. 5. Hyperconjugation
  6. 6. Fission & Free Radicals
  7. 7. Carbocations
  8. 8. Carbanions
  9. 9. Carbenes
  10. 10. Nitrenes & Benzyne
  11. 11. Electrophiles & Nucleophiles
  12. 12. Reaction Types
  13. 13. Free Radical Substitution
  14. 14. SN2 Reaction
  15. 15. SN1 Reaction
  16. 16. SN1 vs SN2
  17. 17. Electrophilic Substitution
  18. 18. Markovnikov's Rule
  19. 19. Br₂ Addition & Dienes
  20. 20. Peroxide Effect
  21. 21. Nucleophilic Addition
  22. 22. E1, E1cB & Saytzeff
  23. 23. E2 Elimination
Reaction Mechanisms · Part 5 of 23

Hyperconjugation and the Baker–Nathan Effect

Next to a π bond, an empty p orbital or an odd electron, the C–H σ bonds of the neighbouring (α) carbon delocalise too. This σ–π conjugation, hyperconjugation, explains why methyl donates better than tert-butyl to a double bond, why more substituted alkenes and 3° cations are more stable, and why the C–C bond in propene is shorter than in propane. Count the α-hydrogens: each one gives a canonical form.

Builds on: Part 1 · Inductive Effect: −I and +I Groups, Part 4 · Electromeric and Mesomeric (Resonance) Effects.

Hyperconjugation and the Baker–Nathan EffectVideo coming soon
σ–π conjugation

A C–H bond feeds an empty p orbital

A C–H σ bond on the α-carbon, lined up with the empty p orbital of a carbocation (or a π bond, or an odd-electron orbital), shares its electron density with it.

3D model of a carbocation with its empty p orbital and a neighbouring methyl C–H bond aligned with it.
Only H atoms on the α-carbon can do this.
Table of alkyl groups with their α-hydrogen counts.
More α-H, more hyperconjugative forms.
Baker–Nathan order

α-H on the attached carbon

– 3, – 2, – 1, – 0 α-H. On an unsaturated system the donating order is – > – > – > –, the reverse of the +I order.

No-bond resonance

Propene's hyperconjugative forms

Each of propene's three α-H gives a form with no bond drawn between C and .

Propene and its no-bond resonance form.
Three no-bond forms, one per α-H.
But-1-ene and propene with their α-carbons marked.
The end CH₃ of but-1-ene is not α.
Worked example

but-1-ene vs propene

In but-1-ene only the on the double bond is α (2 forms); propene's is α (3 forms).

Evidence

Heats of hydrogenation

kcal/mol: ethene 32.8, propene 30.1, cis-but-2-ene 28.6, trans-but-2-ene 27.6, 2-methylbut-2-ene 26.9. Less heat released means a more stable alkene; trans beats cis because the cis methyls crowd.

Energy levels of five alkenes above the common alkane level.
More substituted, more stable.
Ladder of alkenes ranked by number of α-hydrogens.
Count α-H to rank alkenes.
Stability

More α-H, more stable

(12 α-H) > (9) > (6) > monosubstituted alkenes. This is the basis of Saytzeff's rule. (The book lists but-1-ene above propene; the two are about equal.)

Intermediates

Carbocations: 9, 6, 3, 0

tert-Butyl (9 forms) > isopropyl (6) > ethyl (3) > methyl (0); radicals follow the same order. Cations (6 electrons) gain more than radicals (7).

tert-butyl, isopropyl, ethyl and methyl cations with α-carbons highlighted.
3° > 2° > 1° > CH₃⁺.
Bar chart of bond lengths in propane, propene and acetaldehyde.
Partial double-bond character shortens the bond.
Consequences

Bond lengths and dipoles

Propene's –C is 1.46 Å (propane 1.54 Å); its C=C lengthens to 1.353 Å (1.334 Å). Acetaldehyde: –C 1.50 Å, C=O 1.21 Å. μ rises from HCHO 2.27 D to 2.72 D.

Summary

Key formulas

Evidence: heat of hydrogenation and alkene stability
Bond lengths, dipole moment and orientation
Bond lengths, dipole moment and orientation
Worked examples

One for every idea

σ–π conjugation and the Baker–Nathan effect

1. How many hyperconjugative structures can be drawn for but-1-ene ()? Compare it with propene.

  1. Only the attached to the sp² carbon is α: 2 H, so 2 forms.
  2. Propene's is α with 3 H: 3 forms.

But-1-ene 2, propene 3: propene has more hyperconjugation.

Evidence: heat of hydrogenation and alkene stability

2. Arrange in increasing stability: ethene, 2-methylpropene, propene, 2,3-dimethylbut-2-ene. Use α-H counts.

  1. α-H: ethene 0, propene 3, 2-methylpropene 6, 2,3-dimethylbut-2-ene 12.

Ethene < propene < 2-methylpropene < 2,3-dimethylbut-2-ene.

Stability of carbocations and free radicals by hyperconjugation

3. How many hyperconjugative structures does the isopropyl cation, , have? How does it compare with the tert-butyl cation?

  1. Two groups × 3 H = 6 α-H: 6 forms.
  2. tert-Butyl: 3 × 3 = 9.

6; tert-butyl (9) is more stable.

Bond lengths, dipole moment and orientation

4. Why is the C–C single bond in propene shorter than the C–C bond in propane?

  1. Hyperconjugation gives forms in which the –CH bond is a double bond.

The real bond has partial double-bond character: 1.46 Å vs 1.54 Å.

JEE-style question

Your turn

Which alkene has the largest number of hyperconjugative structures?

(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
Show the answer and the traps

(CH₃)₂C=CHCH₃, option d: three α-carbons, 9 α-H.

Propene has only 3 α-H.

2-Methylpropene has 6.

And but-2-ene also has 6.

Watch out

Common mistakes

Counting H atoms that are not on the α-carbonOnly the carbon attached to the sp² (or cationic, radical) carbon counts.
Thinking a tert-butyl group shows hyperconjugationIts α-carbon has no H. (The tert-butyl cation is different: its α-carbons are the methyls, 9 α-H.)
Reading a larger heat of hydrogenation as more stableMore heat released means a higher-energy, less stable alkene.
Practice

Try these

1. Which alkene has the lowest heat of hydrogenation? (a) (b) (c) (d)

(d): 12 α-H, the most stable alkene.

2. How many α-hydrogens does 2-methylbut-2-ene have?

9 (three groups on the double-bond carbons).

3. Arrange the radicals in decreasing stability: , , , .

> > > (9, 6, 3, 0 forms).

4. Why is trans-but-2-ene more stable than cis-but-2-ene, although both have 6 α-H?

In the cis isomer the two methyl groups crowd and repel each other.

5. Why does acetaldehyde have a larger dipole moment (2.72 D) than formaldehyde (2.27 D)?

The methyl group releases electrons by hyperconjugation (and +I), increasing the polarity of C=O.

All 23 partsChapter hub