layrd.liveLayer by Layer
ChemistryReaction MechanismsJEE · NEET
  1. 1. Inductive Effect
  2. 2. Carboxylic Acid Strength
  3. 3. Alcohols, Hydrocarbons, Amines
  4. 4. Electromeric & Mesomeric
  5. 5. Hyperconjugation
  6. 6. Fission & Free Radicals
  7. 7. Carbocations
  8. 8. Carbanions
  9. 9. Carbenes
  10. 10. Nitrenes & Benzyne
  11. 11. Electrophiles & Nucleophiles
  12. 12. Reaction Types
  13. 13. Free Radical Substitution
  14. 14. SN2 Reaction
  15. 15. SN1 Reaction
  16. 16. SN1 vs SN2
  17. 17. Electrophilic Substitution
  18. 18. Markovnikov's Rule
  19. 19. Br₂ Addition & Dienes
  20. 20. Peroxide Effect
  21. 21. Nucleophilic Addition
  22. 22. E1, E1cB & Saytzeff
  23. 23. E2 Elimination
Reaction Mechanisms · Part 16 of 23

SN1 vs SN2: Substrate, Leaving Group and Solvent

SN1 is fast when the carbocation is stable, the leaving group good and the solvent polar and ionising; SN2 is fast when the carbon is unhindered, the nucleophile strong and concentrated, and the solvent aprotic. The twelve-point comparison turns those rules into a checklist for choosing the mechanism.

Builds on: Part 15 · SN1 Reaction: Carbocations, Racemisation and Rearrangement.

SN1 vs SN2: Substrate, Leaving Group and SolventVideo coming soon
SN1 factors

Substrate order

, following carbocation stability: benzyl > allyl > 3° > 2° > 1° > methyl. Leaving groups: ≈ , the same order as in SN2 but more important here (slow step).

Ladder of substrates by SN1 reactivity.
The reverse of the SN2 order.
Bar chart of SN1 solvolysis rates in five solvents.
100 000 × faster in water than in ethanol.
SN1 factors

Solvent polarity

Solvolysis of : < 1, 1, 4, 5000, 100 000. Polar solvents with high dielectric constants stabilise the ions forming in the slow step.

Compare

SN2 vs SN1: mechanism

Steps: one vs two. Order: second vs first. Slow-step TS: Nu···C···L vs R⁺···L. Attack: backside only vs both sides (back predominates). Stereochemistry: complete inversion vs racemisation with some inversion.

Table comparing the mechanisms of SN2 and SN1.
The first six points.
Table comparing the conditions for SN2 and SN1.
The remaining points.
Compare

SN2 vs SN1: conditions

RX order: CH₃ > 1° > 2° > 3° vs the reverse; halogens I > Br > Cl > F in both. Rearrangement: none (except allylic) vs possible. Nucleophile: strong, concentrated vs weak, dilute. Solvent: low polarity (aprotic) vs high polarity. Rate set by steric hindrance vs cation stability. Catalysis: none (phase transfer) vs Ag⁺, AlCl₃, ZnCl₂, strong acids.

Worked examples

One for every idea

Substrate, leaving group and solvent in SN1

1. Arrange in decreasing reactivity: , , , .

  1. SN1 follows carbocation stability: benzyl (resonance) ≈ 3° (9 α-H) > 2° > 1°.

≈ (the book's order puts benzyl first).

SN1 vs SN2: the twelve-point comparison

2. Predict the mechanism: (a) + NaCN in DMF; (b) in aqueous formic acid; (c) + (high concentration).

  1. (a) 1° substrate, strong nucleophile, aprotic solvent.
  2. (b) 3° substrate, weak nucleophile, highly polar solvent.
  3. (c) 2° substrate, strong concentrated nucleophile.

(a) SN2; (b) SN1; (c) mostly SN2, with E2 competing.

JEE-style question

Your turn

2-Chloro-2-methylpropane undergoes SN1 solvolysis fastest in:

(a)ethanol
(b)methanol
(c)formic acid
(d)water
Show the answer and the traps

Water, option d: relative rate 100 000, the most ionising of the four.

Ethanol is the slowest, rate 1.

Methanol: only 4.

Formic acid is strongly ionising, 5000, but still well behind water.

Watch out

Common mistakes

Assuming secondary halides always go by SN1With a strong, concentrated nucleophile they follow SN2.
Ignoring the solventPolar protic solvents speed SN1 but slow SN2.
Practice

Try these

1. Which gives the faster SN1 reaction: or ? Why?

: iodide is the better leaving group, and it leaves in the slow step.

2. Allyl chloride reacts by both SN1 and SN2 faster than propyl chloride. Explain.

The allyl cation (SN1) and the SN2 transition state are both stabilised by the adjacent π bond.

3. Why does speed up the SN1 reaction of an alkyl halide?

pulls off the halide (precipitating AgX), helping ionisation (Lewis acid catalysis).

4. Benzyl chloride in water vs benzyl chloride with NaCN in DMSO: which mechanism in each?

Water: SN1 (stable benzyl cation, weak Nu, polar solvent). NaCN/DMSO: SN2 (strong Nu, aprotic solvent, unhindered 1° carbon).

All 23 partsChapter hub