SN1 is fast when the carbocation is stable, the leaving group good and the solvent polar and ionising; SN2 is fast when the carbon is unhindered, the nucleophile strong and concentrated, and the solvent aprotic. The twelve-point comparison turns those rules into a checklist for choosing the mechanism.
Builds on: Part 15 · SN1 Reaction: Carbocations, Racemisation and Rearrangement.
Video coming soon, following carbocation stability: benzyl > allyl > 3° > 2° > 1° > methyl. Leaving groups: ≈ , the same order as in SN2 but more important here (slow step).


Solvolysis of : < 1, 1, 4, 5000, 100 000. Polar solvents with high dielectric constants stabilise the ions forming in the slow step.
Steps: one vs two. Order: second vs first. Slow-step TS: Nu···C···L vs R⁺···L. Attack: backside only vs both sides (back predominates). Stereochemistry: complete inversion vs racemisation with some inversion.


RX order: CH₃ > 1° > 2° > 3° vs the reverse; halogens I > Br > Cl > F in both. Rearrangement: none (except allylic) vs possible. Nucleophile: strong, concentrated vs weak, dilute. Solvent: low polarity (aprotic) vs high polarity. Rate set by steric hindrance vs cation stability. Catalysis: none (phase transfer) vs Ag⁺, AlCl₃, ZnCl₂, strong acids.
1. Arrange in decreasing reactivity: , , , .
≈ (the book's order puts benzyl first).
2. Predict the mechanism: (a) + NaCN in DMF; (b) in aqueous formic acid; (c) + (high concentration).
(a) SN2; (b) SN1; (c) mostly SN2, with E2 competing.
2-Chloro-2-methylpropane undergoes SN1 solvolysis fastest in:
Water, option d: relative rate 100 000, the most ionising of the four.
Ethanol is the slowest, rate 1.
Methanol: only 4.
Formic acid is strongly ionising, 5000, but still well behind water.
: iodide is the better leaving group, and it leaves in the slow step.
The allyl cation (SN1) and the SN2 transition state are both stabilised by the adjacent π bond.
pulls off the halide (precipitating AgX), helping ionisation (Lewis acid catalysis).
Water: SN1 (stable benzyl cation, weak Nu, polar solvent). NaCN/DMSO: SN2 (strong Nu, aprotic solvent, unhindered 1° carbon).