Chemistry › Organic Chemistry › Reaction Mechanisms · Part 17/23
1. Inductive Effect 2. Carboxylic Acid Strength 3. Alcohols, Hydrocarbons, Amines 4. Electromeric & Mesomeric 5. Hyperconjugation 6. Fission & Free Radicals 7. Carbocations 8. Carbanions 9. Carbenes 10. Nitrenes & Benzyne 11. Electrophiles & Nucleophiles 12. Reaction Types 13. Free Radical Substitution 14. SN2 Reaction 15. SN1 Reaction 16. SN1 vs SN2 17. Electrophilic Substitution 18. Markovnikov's Rule 19. Br₂ Addition & Dienes 20. Peroxide Effect 21. Nucleophilic Addition 22. E1, E1cB & Saytzeff 23. E2 Elimination
Reaction Mechanisms · Part 17 of 23
Electrophilic Substitution: SE1 and SE2 in Benzene
Electrophilic substitution (SE ) replaces a group on carbon with an electrophile. In aliphatic compounds the first-order SE1 path is rare; in benzene, SE2 runs in three steps: generate a strong electrophile, let the π cloud attack it to form a resonance-stabilised arenium ion (the slow step), then lose H⁺ to restore aromaticity.
Builds on: Part 4 · Electromeric and Mesomeric (Resonance) Effects , Part 7 · Carbocations: Structure and Stability .
Video coming soon
SE1
Rare, aliphatic A metal replaced by H (C X 2 H X 5 MgBr + H X + C X 2 H X 6 ), silver carboxylate + bromine (RCOOAg + Br X 2 RBr + CO X 2 + AgBr ), and H/D or H/T isotope exchange.
First-order electrophilic substitution.
C₂H₅MgBr + H₂O → C₂H₆ + Mg(OH)Br.
Worked example
Grignard reagent + water The carbon bonded to Mg is electron-rich; H X + from water replaces MgBr: an aliphatic electrophilic substitution.
Step 1
Making the electrophile Cl X 2 + FeCl X 3 Cl X + + FeCl X 4 X − ; HNO X 3 + 2 H X 2 SO X 4 NO X 2 X + + 2 HSO X 4 X − + H X 3 O X + ; 2 H X 2 SO X 4 SO X 3 + HSO X 4 X − + H X 3 O X + ; RCl + AlCl X 3 R X + + AlCl X 4 X − ; RCOCl + AlCl X 3 RCO X + + AlCl X 4 X − .
A Lewis acid or conc. H₂SO₄ is needed.
Three resonance forms.
Step 2
The arenium ion The electrophile bonds to one ring carbon, which becomes sp³ (bearing H and E); the positive charge is shared by the two ortho carbons and the para carbon. This σ-complex is the Wheland intermediate.
Energy
The slow step Forming the arenium ion breaks aromaticity, so the first hump is the high, rate-determining one; loss of H X + (with the catalyst regenerated, e.g. H X + + FeBr X 4 X − FeBr X 3 + HBr ) is fast.
Step 2 is rate-determining.
Acetophenone from benzene.
Worked example
Friedel–Crafts acylation (1) CH X 3 COCl + AlCl X 3 CH X 3 C X + = O + AlCl X 4 X − ; (2) slow attack giving the arenium ion; (3) AlCl X 4 X − removes H X + : C X 6 H X 5 COCH X 3 + HCl + AlCl X 3 .
Worked examples
One for every idea
SE1 in aliphatic compounds
1. In C X 2 H X 5 MgBr + H X 2 O C X 2 H X 6 + Mg ( OH ) Br , what replaces what on carbon, and what kind of reagent attacks?
The C–Mg carbon is electron-rich. H X + from water, an electrophile, replaces MgBr.An aliphatic electrophilic substitution (S E ).
SE2 in benzene: electrophile, arenium ion, proton loss
2. Write the three steps for the Friedel–Crafts acylation of benzene with acetyl chloride and AlCl X 3 .
CH X 3 COCl + AlCl X 3 CH X 3 C X + = O + AlCl X 4 X − .Slow: the π system attacks CH X 3 CO X + , giving a resonance-stabilised arenium ion. Fast: AlCl X 4 X − removes H X + . C X 6 H X 5 COCH X 3 + HCl + AlCl X 3 .
JEE-style question
Your turn
The rate-determining step in the nitration of benzene is:
(a) formation of NO₂⁺
(b) attack of NO₂⁺ on the ring (arenium ion)
(c) loss of H⁺ from the arenium ion
(d) protonation of HNO₃
Show the answer and the traps
Attack of NO₂⁺ on the ring to form the arenium ion, option b: it breaks the aromatic sextet.
Forming NO₂⁺ is a fast acid–base step.
Losing H⁺ is fast: it restores aromaticity.
And protonating HNO₃ is a fast pre-equilibrium.
Watch out
Common mistakes
Making proton loss the slow step Forming the arenium ion (losing aromaticity) is rate-determining.
Letting the arenium ion add a nucleophile It loses H⁺ instead, to restore aromaticity: substitution, not addition.
Practice
Try these
1. In the nitration of benzene, the attacking electrophile is: (a) NO X 2 X − (b) NO X 3 X − (c) NO X 2 X + (d) HNO X 3 (c) the nitronium ion.
2. Why is FeBr X 3 needed for the bromination of benzene but not of ethene? Benzene's aromatic π system is less reactive; FeBr X 3 polarises Br X 2 to give a strong electrophile (Br X + ).
3. How many resonance forms does the arenium ion have, and where is the positive charge? Three; on the two carbons ortho and the carbon para to the sp³ carbon.